Can Elizabeth Warren’s ’50/20/30 rule’ get your finances on track?

Though some say it’s vague, the rule could be useful for middle income earners

Article content

In her 2006 book, All Your Worth: The Ultimate Lifetime Money PlanUS Senator Elizabeth Warren suggested to readers a simple budgeting strategy to help keep their finances in order.


Article content

The “50/20/30 rule,” as Warren and co-author Amelia Warren Tyagi’s approach is typically called, organizes spending into three general categories and dedicates a predetermined portion of your after-tax income to each one.

It’s a fairly straightforward approach to budgeting, but it may not be for everyone. Let’s find out what the 50/20/30 rule is and see if it’s the right strategy for you.

The 50/20/30 rule

The 50/20/30 rule states that your take-home pay should be divvied up as follows:

  • 50 per cent goes toward essentials like rent or mortgage payments, utilities, healthcare costs, insurance, transportation and minimum debt payments.
  • 20 per cent is allotted for savings. That could mean building an emergency fund, paying down high-interest debt or contributing to an education, retirement or investment account, like an RESP, RRSP or TFSA.
  • 30 per cent pays for your wants. Consider these the items and experiences that don’t contribute to your net worth: entertainment, retail goods, upgrading products out of desire rather than necessity, memberships and subscriptions.


Article content

Straightforward as a budget like this seems, it does require discipline to stick to, especially when the lines between categories get blurry.

“I wonder about semantics,” says Stan Tepner, senior wealth advisor at CIBC Wood Gundy. “If I put $1,000 into a TFSA or I pay down my mortgage principal by the same amount of all my monthly payments, is that ‘savings’ or ‘required costs of living’?”

There could also be confusion around what constitutes an “essential” purchase. A gym membership, for example, may receive “essential” designation from someone for whom physical fitness is a requirement at their job. Category-bending like that will be hard to avoid in some cases.

But trying to convince yourself that some of your wants are needs, and slipping more of your discretionary spending into your “essential” category, defeats the purpose of 50/20/30.


Article content

In these cases, your wants are really just masquerading as needs, taking up more than their allotted 30 per cent. The money to pay for them has to come from somewhere, and it’ll likely be from the 20 per cent that’s supposed to be meant for savings.

“Having a budget can be a difference-maker, but it’s only a difference-maker if it is used for the purpose that it was created,” says Tepner.

How realistic is the 50/20/30 rule?

Like any budgeting strategy, 50/20/30 won’t be a fit for everyone. Depending on your financial situation, it might not be realistic at all.

If you’re earning $45,000 in Toronto, for example, you would take home just under $3,000 a month. With the average rent in the city being $2,013, it would be difficult, if not impossible, to allocate only 50 per cent of your net earnings to essentials every month. A similar scenario faces homeowners paying off large mortgages.


Article content

What if you’re making even less? Statistics Canada data shows that in 2019, over 13 million Canadians earned less than $35,000 a year. After essentials are paid off, a modest income like that doesn’t leave much for discretionary spending, let alone savings.

Adhering to 50/20/30 may not even be ideal for the wealthy, for whom essentials likely won’t demand 50 per cent of their monthly income. In these cases, putting only 20 per cent of your earnings into savings would be a missed opportunity.

50/20/30 may be best leveraged by middle-class earners who have cash left over at the end of the month — but who need a little help in deciding how best to use it.

No matter which income bracket you fall into, 50/20/30 is a useful starting point for your budgeting needs. If nothing else, it can help you prioritize your spending and clarify which expenses are preventing you from saving more every month.

And really, no one’s going to fault you if 60/10/30 or 70/10/20 is the best you can do. You won’t be letting Elizabeth Warren down. The important thing is that you recognize the importance of a budget, the role it can play in firming up your finances and stick to it the best you can.

“With any budget strategy,” Tepner says, “set it, stick to it, evaluate your results and update it for the next budget period. Rinse and repeat.”

This article provides information only and should not be construed as advice. It is provided without warranty of any kind.



Postmedia is committed to maintaining a lively but civil forum for discussion and encourage all readers to share their views on our articles. Comments may take up to an hour for moderation before appearing on the site. We ask you to keep your comments relevant and respectful. We have enabled email notifications—you will now receive an email if you receive a reply to your comment, there is an update to a comment thread you follow or if a user you follow comments. Visit our Community Guidelines for more information and details on how to adjust your email settings.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to top button